IronPort-PHdr: A9a23:8SITtRLSgEh4GKW3HdmcuKtgWUAX047cFxMJ6pchl7NFe7ii+JKnB
               kHE+PFxlzfhR4jf4uMCluzX9qDtWGAN5ZyMqn9EfJEfHwQdh5AwmAotSNWAFVW9NOTjOiIgF
               cJBElpk4222NUJcE8bWY1TOr2339SQVGBj0KUxyPOumUpXKgZGP3vups4bWfx0OgTO8Zb1oK
               xDjox/YsMpQhIp+Nqs1wBLColNMcvhb1SZwP1WRkh3goMCq880r6Dxe7tQm8cMISqDmZ+I4Q
               LhfWSwhKHww7db3uAPrRgyK63cNFGkflAZFRQTIhDnAU5z8szX3uq9G4AfyFevxS718GS6v6
               656DgLuiWIHOj81/WXdh9Z/yq5W8lqnoFRkzojYbZvwVrI2d77Bfd4cWWtKX9pAHy1HDISma
               oITDu0Hde9Gpoj5rlEKoFOwHw6pTO/ozzZJgDfx08hYm6wvCwjA30olHs4SvXDepd71HKMbT
               e2libHSyjfOZO8Q3i3yqcDJfh0nvfCQTOdoa8OCrCtnXwjBj1iWtcnkJ2bIkL9Q9TLHvqw+D
               bHnkWMspgBvryL63Moog5iPm4QUj1DJ9Cl0xIw4P9L+REMoBLzsWJZWqSyeMJN7B804RGQ98
               iggw7sF/5u6YDQHzJ4uzB73b/WbfpjN+gjkVuuaPXF/nn0vK9fdz16itFOtzOHxTJz+3kxDq
               CkDl9jQqn0J3RXY6uCDQ+dw7gK5wzGN2gvPrOZeLgpn8MiTY45kybk2mJ0JtE3FFSKjg0T6g
               pidcUA88/Sp4eDqCp3cq5SRNpF5hkTFCopGsvS2Gv9wchIDW2GKv/m61fjj8Ez1TbFAg+c51
               KXU4tjWIsESp6jxBAEwsM5r5Qy2CTTg1dUEgXQDJltOeDqDhpTkKxTWOvf6APyjxVO2n39ny
               uvHMbvoHpjWZiWFy+qnJ+osrRAEgAMoqLIXr4pZELQAPO7+VgfqudrUAwV4ew24zuD7Cclsg
               4YXWGaBGKicY+vZtV6F4P5qIvHZOclO5XCnd6ljuaa96B1x0UUQdqSow5YNPWq1Gv13ZVifY
               D/sj9YNHGMAsxAxCuDn2zjgGXZeYWi/W6Uk63Q1EoWjWM3NXImrg/qE3TunE5lcb2tGIlSFD
               Xr4Mp2eXPUBYz7UJdVu2G9hN/DpW8o62BeiuRWvgbR9J+zXvCgZqY7u0NJ87O37kRgu+CwxF
               96a0WyGUydzhGxCFFpUlOhv5Ed6zFmEy61xhfdVQMdS6/1+WQA/LZfAzuZ+BoO6Skfbc9yOU
               lrjXsS+DGR7UIcq29FXKRUYeZ3qnlXZ0iGtGbNQi7GbGMl+7PfHx3aob8Ntg2DP0K1r53EcT
               8BCNHOriutEzya7L6jOlUjR17ynca0NmjPL9SKDwGuCsUVSXRR/F6nIDzgZYQPNoNL161mnL
               ffmAKk7MgZH1c+JK7dbItzvg1JcQf7/OdPYK2uvkma0DByMy/uCdo3vM2ka2SzcDgADnWVxt
               T6eMhMiAy66v2/EJDdpEF/jcgXg+O9ipTW3Qw58zg2HaVFgy6vg+hMRgq/5Kbtb1bYFtSE97
               jRsSQv7hI+QUYbR4VQ5L+1GbNgw4UlKzzfDugh0L9q9KaEnhlMffwlztU702FN7B9Yl84Bio
               XU0wQ51Ma/d3klGcmbS04r5PL6RL2ju4B2rYafd2nna2cqb6uIX8vM6pl7/+gazGQBxlhcvm
               8kQyHaa6pjQWUAKVontV08s6xVgj7rdZyQx9sXY3HtwPO+4v3WRvrBhTPtgwRGmcdBFNaqCH
               wKnCMwWCf+lL+kykkSoZBYJVMhisZUsNsbjTMOonbaxNY5ImDu6gHQC+Jp60E+H62x7UOGah
               /4t87SjxgKCEgzEohKhv8Tw8ahPYjQfEnv5xSHiGIMXaqAgJe4jOSKVO8Syg+5GqdvoUn9c+
               kSkAjsu3Ma1dArXd0b63wBbyQIQu3P1wEOF
IronPort-HdrOrdr: A9a23:BPxuUKowQ1dOSpHKkVYTWmcaV5tlL9V00zAX/kB9WHVpW+afkN
                  2jm+le8BfyhioYVn1Io6HmBICrR3TA+ZlppbQLNbC5UwX8/EeuJodu7YztqgeQfRHW3OhbyK
                  tmbuxCGMT9ZGIK6frSzSuZN5IbwNeB+L21nuu29R1QZCxjdq0I1WdEIymBFEkefmd7LLo/UK
                  GR/89W4wenEE5nC/iTIlkgc6z9q8bQlJTgCCR2ZSIPzAWVlzun5PrbPnGjvys2aD9Ezbc8/W
                  WtqWWQjZmLiP21xgTR0GXe9f1t9+fJ8MdJB8CHl6EuRwnEtwDAXuhccoGZsCtwiO+i70tCqq
                  iunz4Qe+lazE78OlutqR+o4QPnyzpG0Q6a9XaoxUHoqcv/SD9/INopv/MgTifk
References: <F9F9D8FE-A1E6-4E89-AB97-CD9D85D5C8F4@gmail.com>
User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10.16; rv:78.0)
            Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/78.7.1
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8; format=flowed
Content-Language: en-US
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit
Message-ID:  <2fb7783e-5770-b952-8def-7950d31478ac@latex-project.org>
Date:         Mon, 22 Mar 2021 18:27:53 +0100
Reply-To:     Mailing list for the LaTeX3 project
              <LATEX-L@LISTSERV.UNI-HEIDELBERG.DE>
Sender:       Mailing list for the LaTeX3 project <LATEX-L@LISTSERV.UNI-HEIDELBERG.DE>
From:         Frank Mittelbach <frank.mittelbach@LATEX-PROJECT.ORG>
Subject: Re: Bug in fontdef.dtx?
To:           LATEX-L@LISTSERV.UNI-HEIDELBERG.DE
In-Reply-To:  <F9F9D8FE-A1E6-4E89-AB97-CD9D85D5C8F4@gmail.com>
Precedence: list
Envelope-To: <rainer.schoepf@gmx.net>
Status: R

Hi Don,

long time no see

> fontdef.dtx defines the various series, family and style defaults
> using \newcommand, e.g.
> 
> \newcommand\itdefault{it} \newcommand\sldefault{sl} 
> \newcommand\scdefault{sc} \newcommand\updefault{up}
> 
> This gives defines them as \long However, the commands \fontfamily,
> \fontseries and \fontshape define \f@family, \f@series and \f@shape
> using \edef which maked the resulting values not \long

a bit inconsistent I agree, but as Joseph said "like this forever" and 
also like this in other places, so even if fontdef would change you 
couldn't rely on it not being made long
> 
> This means that code that would do something like, e.g.,
> \ifx\f@shape\itdefault…\fi will not work as expected.

yes, but that is not a reliable test anyway.

\def\familydefault{cmr}
\def\familydefault{\rmdefault}

point to the same family as a default but your test would pick them up 
as different regardless.

The only reliable test is something like

\edef\next{\itdefault}
\ifx\f@shape\next ...

and that is how NFSS always treats them internally.

> The simplest fix would be to use the starred form of \newcommand for
> setting the various \XXdefault values. I would imagine that this
> should not break anything

I'm sure from experience that your imagination is faulty :-) it will 
break something as any change does, but beside that it will not resolve 
the problem. There are many classes and packages which use \renewcommand 
on them and so may the user in the preamble, so even if we would change 
(after 30 years) it isn't really going to help, you need to expand the 
value prior to testing it against \f@...  (which are ensured to be *not* 
long).

So I agree with Joseph (albeit for a slightly different reason), a 
feature not a bug.

cheers
frank